This is an email we received from a client. Her challenges are pretty common, and I thought other people might be able to relate, and might find our advice to her helpful. “Names have been removed to protect the innocent.”
“I’m having serious problems with dog. Monday thru Friday I have to leave her alone in the yard while I’m at work for about 9 hrs each day. She was ok for the 1st five months but starting last July when the neighbors were lighting fireworks she got really scared one day climbed the fence and made a run for it to the neighbor’s house. Once she figured out that there was freedom and a very friendly neighbor who feeds her and who has friendly dogs and a child who adores her living at the end of the block, she has since been very determined to escape. Every time she gets out she goes straight to their house and will stay in or very near their yard until they come home. I’ve asked them to not let her in or feed her and to just tie her in their front yard and leave her there so I can come get her and she doesn’t run away but its been difficult to get them to do it. They love her and want to play with her, feed her, cuddle her etc. I have tried everything I can think of to prevent her escape. I’ve moved everything away from the fences, replaced boards and lined portions of the fence with huge sheets of plywood, even extended parts of the fence that face the front yard up to 10′ high. I have an invisible fence system and a shock collar that she wears during the day it has slowed her down but when determined, she still finds a way out. I have tethered her and she will destroy things in her surroundings and rub the cable against her skin in effort to get away until the fur is gone.
This is definitely an anxiety issue, not just a boredom thing. She has seriously injured herself in her panic and done a lot of damaged to the property. She has toys galore, a cat buddy who plays with her and stays with her in the yard, food and water and an entire futon couch. I know exercise would help but I simply can not take her for a walk/run in the morning before I go to work. Last summer when the issue began I would leave the back door open for her and usually as long as she had access to the house she would not escape but at this time of the year I can not leave the door open, cold and mud are not allowed in the house. Plus, it’s just not a good idea.
I have left her in the house on a couple of occasions all day and she was okay, no damages other than the unintentional wreckage of things being moved around when she plays with the kitty cat. But no chewing or potty issues. However, I don’t want to leave her in the house all day. That’s to long to be cooped up, especially when she has a fabulous yard she
could be playing in and she may eventually start to destroy things indoors. Dont want to risk it.
Any suggestions? Please help I’m at my wits end.”
–
Our response:
“This is one of those critical junctures that emphasizes the importance of leadership and consistency. It’s really hard when we have full-time jobs and any kind of commute – we’re not home as much as we feel we should be. But that’s life, and that’s reality. So what we need to do is take control of whatever leadership we can when we’re NOT at home, and make the most of the time we DO have at home.
Everything she is going through right now is based on success after success after success. It may be negative – or not, as when it comes to your neighbors interacting with her – it’s all self reward. We need to give her success at something else.
Hers is also a perfect example of JOBS — she has so much to be in control of – the back yard, the interior when you leave the door open, the cat, the fence, the squirrels, the neighbors, YOU – there’s so much for her to be in charge of, she can’t just be a dog.
So let’s go back to square one — we need to take away her ability to make decisions. If we don’t, she’s going to keep making the same decisions, and you know how that’s (not) working
.
She does need to be contained. We need to force a change of habit. I know you don’t want to keep her indoors in a kennel for endless hours at a time, day after day, however, some heavy-duty kennel time is a very effective way to change habits. It removes all ability or option for her to make decisions. If you can get home mid-day and let her out to potty — or maybe your neighbor could do that for you? as they seem to have taken a shine to her?? At least that would give her a potty break and ease some anxieties I’m sure you’ll have about extended kenneling for a while.
Give that a couple of weeks (like you would if she was recovering from a surgery or something, when you have no CHOICE but to keep her contained and quiet. This is similar – you have no option but to eliminate her choices and change the outcome for her) and then try confining her to a dog run outside. It’s a lot less space that she is required to control compared to your back yard, your front yard, the neighbor’s hard, the neighbor’s house, your house, etc… You’ll want to invest in a sturdy top for the run, as she will probably learn to climb out of it otherwise…. And if you can put it on cement, or bury chicken wire at an angle into the run, she won’t be able to dig out. You’ll also want to buy one of the pre-assembled units — the ones where you have to string the chain link yourself just never get tight enough and I’m sure she’ll learn to squeeze her way out in no time.
So take some big steps back and think of all the ways you can remove her ability to make decisions, and any way you can change her habits. And in doing so, we need to replace them with new, positive, non-scary habits — not that you have a lot of control of your neighbors letting off fire works, but…
Regarding physically exercising her, and feeling guilty because you’re not…
You can’t feel guilty – it doesn’t do anyone any good. And at this stage, I’m not sure physically exercising her is the answer. When you have the kinds of changes that you’ve had with the job, the hours away, etc, Leadership inherently slips. Depending on how consistent you were prior to the changes, it could slip a LOT. So take some biiig steps back with Leadership, and get your relationship back under control. Practice all those little things that have probably fallen by the way-side: sit, down, stand, watch-me, leave it, forward/backward, go-find, wait, miniature re-calls. Not only will this reinforce your relationship and your position as the leader, it’s mental engagement for her. If we can mentally wear her out, that’s far more effective than making her more and more physically endurant where she requires extensive daily physical exercise that you can’t give her.
She is having some separation anxiety, so the added plus of increased mental stimulation focusing on Leadership and relationship is that the increased focus on your consistency and leadership should help with her anxiety during the day. The other thing that is going to play a serious role in the anxiety is letting go of your own guilt. We feel badly for leaving them, for how little time we’re spending with them, for how little physical exercise they’re getting, etc etc etc, and we lax on Leadership, we coddle them, and we teach them to be neurotic. Remember to think about it from a canine perspective. ANY guilt you feel is canine-interpreted as weakness and an inability to control her environment. If you’re weak, she has to be in charge, and I think she’s effectively proven she’s not capable of that!
So, love your dog, but don’t coddle her, and don’t feel guilty for anything you just can’t do.
So:
1). Dramatically decrease her living space — giving her MORE space only gives her more to worry about
2). Change the daily habits — reducing her living space will inherently help this
3). Make the time you have quality — practice your tasks and focus on leadership
4). Come back out to the park any time you have time! Sometimes we just need a refresher, and someone else to be accountable to.”